Snacking — When It Helps and When It Doesn't
Nov. 16/26
In apricot season, a warm one off the tree never counted as anything. You split it open standing in the row, ate it, and kept walking. Nobody called it a snack, and nobody wrote down what time it was.
The time part is what I've been thinking about, after reading a small study in the journal Diabetes & Metabolism. Seventeen young women without diabetes wore flash glucose monitors for seven days. On three of those days they ate identical test meals, plus the same slice of cake, about five hundred calories, at half past noon, half past three, and half past seven in the evening. The only thing that changed was the hour.
em-consulte
The evening cake came out worst. Compared with the mid-afternoon cake, the after-dinner one gave bigger glucose swings and higher readings after dinner, and higher readings after the next morning's breakfast too. Same cake, same women, same week, and the hour made the difference.
nih
Anybody who's irrigated knows something like it. The same water behaves differently depending on when you turn it on and what the ground is already carrying. A snack on top of dinner is water on ground that's still full.
I'll say plainly what this study is. Seventeen people, average age around twenty-one, healthy, three days, one kind of cake. I'm a long way past twenty-one, and so are most of the people reading this. A big slice of cake also isn't most people's snack. Nobody in that study was handed an apple or a handful of nuts, so it can't tell you whether a snack helps. It tells you when one particular cake landed hardest. The authors' own conclusion was that sweet snacks after dinner are best avoided. That's a reasonable reading of what they saw, and I'd hold it about as loosely as they gathered it. A week with a monitor is a sample, not a season.
What I notice is how little the question "is snacking good or bad" gets at. Whether it helps or hurts seems to turn on the hour, the size, and what came before it. At Sagewood the dining room sets the meals, and a printed menu for the coming week arrives every Saturday so I can see what's ahead. Nothing on that menu covers the hours in between. That part is mine, and nobody's checking.
Plenty of us have reached for something between meals without being hungry. Sometimes it's the clock. Sometimes it's a long afternoon, or the plate sitting there in reach. A snack can be fuel, or it can be a habit wearing fuel's clothes, and from the outside they look about the same.
This week's habit is simple enough: for seven days, write down every snack, with the time, and set it next to your Libre 3 data. At the end of the week, read the two together and see what your own ground has to say.
The monitor will tell you what the snack did and when. It won't tell you what you were after when you reached for it, and I suspect that's the part worth knowing.
This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice.
Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before making changes to your diet, medications, or health routine.
The reader is always the final decision-maker.
From the Field:
Food Safety Recalls & Outbreaks — https://www.foodsafety.gov/recalls-and-outbreaks
Blue Zones — bluezones.com
Oldways / Mediterranean Diet — oldwayspt.org
Read more at https://gardener-of-life.com
If this resonates, buy me a coffee — it keeps the field notes coming.
https://buymeacoffee.com/gardeneroflife
This post is free through December 31, 2027. Starting January 1, 2028, Gardener of Life moves to a paid membership.